Wargamer : no score but this summary : "Uncommon Valor is a spectacular operational level wargame that provides players with an unparalleled level of depth in the way it portrays the air, land and naval forces of both combatants and the deadly engagements in the WWII Pacific Area. The sheer magnitude of the theatre, the level of realism, the freedom of choice and the amount of control players have over their forces will ensure that Uncommon Valor keeps players thoroughly engrossed in the South Pacific for many hours to come"
: a 8.2 final score with this comment "While Uncommon Valor isn't for the inattentive gamer, it's got more potential for popular appeal than most wargames. The broad-reach of the game doesn't come at the expense of detail or flexibility though, so it shouldn't put off the hardcore crowd
Domain : a 4 out of 5 score with this comment "It's one of those rare games that manages to combine detail, historical accuracy and playability to make a truly engaging and entertaining strategy game"
: a 7.8 score - you need a Gamespot Complete Access in order to read the
: a 75 score with this comment : "No, it's not flashy, easy, or interface-friendly, but those who take the time to appreciate its ambiance, study its nuances, and master its interface will be rewarded with hundreds of hours of play."
Gamer Online : No score but the final comment : "On an after note, I would like to commend to game developers for the way they have made such a complex game which is relatively easy to pick up and learn"
- link broken
: you need to be a CombatSim subscriber to read this review
(in croatian) : a 93% score - link broken